TIL Werner Herzog convinced Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni to keep Grogu as a puppet instead of CGI on the set of “The Mandalorian.” After watching them shoot a take without the puppet to allow a CGI replacement in post-production, Herzog told them, “You are cowards. Leave it.”

Werner Herzog persuaded the creators of ‘The Mandalorian’ to keep Grogu as a puppet rather than replace him with CGI, emphasizing the importance of practical effects for authenticity. This decision reflects Herzog’s strong opinions on the character’s portrayal, impacting how the series maintains its tactile feel.

During the production of season 1 of ‘The Mandalorian,’ Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni considered filming two versions of scenes with and without Grogu’s puppet, to decide between practical effects and CGI. Favreau explained they shot both options, intending to choose the best in post-production. Herzog, who played The Client in season 1, filmed a scene with and without the puppet and reportedly told the creators, ‘You are cowards. Leave it. Leave it,’ urging them to keep the puppet. Favreau and Filoni acknowledged Herzog’s strong stance, which ultimately influenced their decision to retain the puppet for its naturalistic qualities and emotional authenticity.

Why It Matters

This development underscores the ongoing debate in visual effects about the value of practical effects versus CGI. Herzog’s influence highlights a preference for tangible, real-world puppetry to foster genuine actor reactions and audience engagement. It also emphasizes the importance of artistic integrity in character portrayal, which can impact the show’s reception and legacy.

Background

‘The Mandalorian’ debuted in 2019, revitalizing interest in practical effects within the Star Wars franchise. The decision to use puppetry for Grogu was initially uncertain, with some considering CGI as a more flexible option. Herzog’s involvement in season 1 as The Client and his outspoken opinions on the puppet versus CGI debate contributed to the emphasis on practical effects. The series has since become known for its blend of digital and practical techniques, with fans often praising the tangible feel of characters like Grogu.

“We wanted to try using the old techniques, then you could always fall back on the CG one if it didn’t work.”

— Jon Favreau

“He [Herzog] said, ‘What are you doing?’ about the puppet removal for the clean plate shot. He was so committed.”

— Dave Filoni

“It was so awesome.”

— Jon Favreau

What Remains Unclear

It is not yet clear if Herzog’s influence will lead to a broader preference for puppetry in future Star Wars projects or if it was an isolated case specific to ‘The Mandalorian’ season 1.

What’s Next

Future seasons of ‘The Mandalorian’ and other Star Wars series may continue to favor practical effects for characters like Grogu. Industry insiders and fans will watch for any official statements or changes in effect techniques. The ongoing debate about CGI versus puppetry remains relevant as new technology develops.

Key Questions

Did Werner Herzog directly influence the decision to keep Grogu as a puppet?

Yes. Herzog’s strong opinions during filming of season 1 reportedly persuaded the creators to retain the puppet for its authenticity and emotional impact.

Will future Star Wars projects continue to use puppets for characters like Grogu?

It is not confirmed, but Herzog’s influence suggests a possible preference for practical effects in future productions to preserve authenticity.

What are the advantages of using puppets over CGI for characters like Grogu?

Puppets provide tactile interaction, natural actor reactions, and a tangible presence that enhances emotional authenticity in scenes.

Has Herzog commented publicly on his influence on the series?

There are no public statements from Herzog about his influence; most information comes from behind-the-scenes accounts and interviews with Favreau and Filoni.

Source: reddit